Statement of Ethical Concerns Regarding Conduct of a Former Treaty Researcher

Anishinaabek Clans to invoke our Nation

We wish to raise a number of serious ethical concerns involving the conduct of a former treaty researcher who was previously engaged by a First Nation to undertake research on behalf of the community. It has come to our attention that research materials produced during the course of that engagement were not fully provided to the specific First Nation, despite the work having been funded and intended for community use. This outcome raises important questions about professional responsibility, contractual obligations, and the safeguarding of information that rightfully belongs to the First Nation.

Furthermore, it is a matter of concern that this individual can be seen as publicly presenting himself as an Indigenous historian without recognized academic accreditation in the field, while simultaneously utilizing research initially funded by the community for personal career advancement. While individuals have the right to pursue professional paths, it is essential that such pursuits do not involve the withholding of information from the Nations that commissioned the work, nor the misrepresentation of qualifications or expertise.

We are also concerned about reported instances in which this individual has publicly criticized or disparaged Indigenous activists, advocates, and community members who are working in good faith to advance the rights, histories, and interests of their Nations. Public commentary that undermines or discredits Indigenous community members without evidence or accountability is harmful, unprofessional, and contrary to the principles of respectful engagement within Indigenous research and advocacy.

For these reasons, we are requesting that:

1. All research materials funded by the Nation be returned or made available in full, as they are community property and vital to ongoing governance, treaty work, and historical preservation.

2. Professional standards and ethical research practices be upheld, particularly regarding transparency, accuracy, and respect for Indigenous knowledge systems.

3. Public representations of expertise be truthful and clearly stated, to avoid misleading communities, partners, or the public.

4. Public commentary about Indigenous activists and community members be conducted respectfully, without personal attacks, insinuations, or unsubstantiated claims.

This statement is made in the interest of integrity, accountability, and the protection of Indigenous community rights. Our intention is not to diminish any individual’s contributions, but to ensure that work funded and entrusted by First Nations is treated with the respect and responsibility it deserves.

We remain committed to promoting ethical research practices and supporting Indigenous communities in safeguarding their histories, voices, and futures.

#AnishinabekNation #IndigenousHistory #IndigenousAcademia #YellowheadInstitute #Pretendians #unionofontarioindians #chiefsofontario